Have you noticed that people are getting more and more compulsive about things that really don’t matter? In the name of thorough mothering or good parenting they are elevating odd things to high levels of importance. Let’s take a look at hand washing, for example.
I am going to just go ahead and rock the internet and say that I never wash my hands. Never is a strong word, and of course I’m exaggerating, but I only wash my hands when they are yucky or dirty. Here are some examples of when I might wash my hands. I wash them when I come in from the garden and have dirt/mud all up in my fingernails and I need to get a splinter out of someone’s eye. I wash my hands when I am dealing with raw meat excessively. Not because I think I’m going to die of a bacterial situation, but because it’s sticky and my phone is probably ringing. Back in the day, I might have washed after changing an explosive diaper. I think I might have washed them after this situation, but it was a symbolic washing. As in, ‘I have an unusual feeling in my gut right now and it’s time to move forward with a clean slate'.
I have never encouraged my children to wash their hands that much. I don’t believe that the invisible germ force is our worst enemy. I can’t cede them that much power. We are meant to live together harmoniously, because neither of us is going anywhere. I’m not stupid. I get how germs, viruses, and such are spread, but I don’t think we’re that fragile. I don’t want to become that fragile. Hand sanitizer is effective for two minutes (fact), and is recommended after contact with a foreign surface, which would make us all neurotic freaks if used as indicated. I touched a door knob, or a keyboard at the library, or that bag of groceries, or your welcoming hand, or a hug from a friend. No thanks. In the name of strengthening my immune system, I’ll politely decline.
These days, everything is ‘dirty’. I went on a field trip with Della and it was sweet, but at the same time a veritable minefield of impending doom. I wanted to bitch slap one of the other parents. (Never a good feeling, except that I can embrace the fantasy and run with it.) You’ve held a barn yard animal? God forbid! A darling yellow chick? #&*@&! WHERE IS THE HAND SANITIZER?!? Oh wait, it’s in a dispenser on that jack-wipes fanny pack. Kids line up for absolution. Because baby chicks are filthy? I herd my precious child away from the neurotic daddy so she can be mauled by baby goats with no associated guilt. This trip to the farm was brought to you by Purell, Germ-X, and the CDC.
When I was growing up, we didn’t talk much about hand washing. You washed them if they were dirty. I have had to write letters to teachers forbidding my child from using hand sanitizer because it was used so excessively. Just teach them how to use punctuation, alright already? I didn’t say that, but it’s what I was thinking.
Someone said that cleanliness is next to Godliness. I don’t think it’s biblical and I don’t care enough to google it, but what I think they meant was that we should be reasonably clean, that the plague was unpleasant and total squalor might contribute to your chances of contracting it. They weren’t giving permission for OCD behaviors.
I teach loads of children in many different arenas. They sniff and snuffle. I’m pretty darn healthy. Every now and then I get a bug. Same with my kids. I think we're average. I like to think that our immune systems are in cahoots with our environmental factors.
Which is to say, that me and my grubby little family are just fine, thanks.
loved this. i do make my kids wash their hands when we get home from runnung errands or if they'd been digging the dirt while playing. i loathe all of that hand sanitizer stuff and the moms with a dispenser attached to each kids' backpack, in their car, their purse...people are out of touch with how to build a healthy and strong immune system!
ReplyDeletesorry for the typo...i'm out of practice typing with one hand!
ReplyDeleteI am hugging this post!
ReplyDeleteI am loving this post!
Deliciously peppered with Fbombs and wisdom: it's just dirty and tasty and good.
I adore this. I feel the EXACT SAME WAY.
ReplyDeleteOh my goodness! I've been living a double life with hand washing for years now! Carrying the customary purse size hand sanitizer to playdates but only using it if Im being watched. You may just help me come out of the closet! Haha! In fact my in-laws have been visiting for the past week which means my boys have been washing their hands like crazy. The look they give me when I tell them to wash their hands is priceless, but I shoot them one right back hoping they wont spill our dirty little secret! Wonder how many more of us are out there?
ReplyDeleteHelp! I think I might be in trouble here as I hold baby chickens [and their momma's too] and don't ever use hand sanitizer!!!!
ReplyDeleteFrom one grubby mom to another, you are welcome at my table anytime!
What is more neurotic? Making your kids bathe in hand sanitizer or feeling the need to justify your not using it on the internet?
ReplyDeleteI keep a sanitizer in my purse for stuff like leaving the play area at the mall. We wash hands after the bathroom, coming home from somewhere like the library or grocery store, and I just recently found myself loving the foaming soap which you can only get antibacterial. Other than that, it's catch as catch can. I am not hyper sensitive about hand washing. I like germs. My kids rarely get what the other kids do, and I think it's BECAUSE I let them get "germy!"
ReplyDeleteGreat post!
word.
ReplyDeleteLove the new look Ivey!! And I LOL at this post. Awesome. I wash my hands when they are really dirty from digging or painting, or if I am in a really nasty public bathroom. That's it. And my kids, well, I think boys should always wash their hands after going to the bathroom, just sayin'. But I know the kind of germiphobes you are talking about. I have met them too. Have you seen the documentary "Babies"? I think every mom who is even slightly germiphobic should watch it. It follows 4 babies in 4 different countries, including Namibia whose babies grow up in the dirt. And you are right about our immune systems and the environment, dirt is not a bad thing--until we start abusing antibacterial and create stronger strains of bacteria. Too much antibacterial is a BAD thing! Thanks for sharing this, loved it :).
ReplyDeletexo
@Erin there is a lovely natural foaming soap from Kiss My Face- just soap no triclosan (the antibacterial stuff that is leading to antibiotic resistant bacteria).
ReplyDeleteI am not worried about dirt or baby animal dirt, but I am worried about touching gas pumps and the like after people who don't wash the poop off of their hands! And since I get a sinus infection every time we get a rhino virus in the house, I am pretty concerned with avoiding those germs. But you are probably right, we would likely get sick or not at the same rate...and my winter hands would be softer:)
You're a riot and I HATE hand sanitizer! We live near Philly which I consider one of the dirtiest cities I know and I still won't use it. I also use the 5 second rule if food drops on the kitchen floor. My grandsons think this game is blast as we scurry to pick up a runaway, organic bunny cookie, blow it off and pop it in our mouths!
ReplyDeleteYou're a riot and I HATE hand sanitizer! We live near Philly which I consider one of the dirtiest cities I know and I still won't use it. I also use the 5 second rule if food drops on the kitchen floor. My grandsons think this game is blast as we scurry to pick up a runaway, organic bunny cookie, blow it off and pop it in our mouths!
ReplyDeleteOh anonymous, no worries. I think we could say that a blog is, by it's very nature, a bit neurotic...after all, I have designed a web site about....me! The nerve! :) and perhaps I touched a nerve. If we can't laugh at neurotic behaviors then what can we laugh at. I always like to start with my own...hope your weekend is lovely and thanx for reading!
ReplyDeleteI ONLY use sanitizer after "passing the peace" at church -- I think of it as holy water.
ReplyDeleteYou read my mind.
ReplyDeleteYou are preaching to the choir. Amen, sister.
ReplyDeleteWhoah. Love this. But I will admit, when we are at a friend's house, and everyone is dutifully expected to file off and wash hands before dinner (which we, um, never do), I just cheerfully go along with it. Nor do I encourage it when my kids say loudly, wow, we NEVER wash our hands before we eat. (which is totally not true: the day they found a dead bird, I made them wash their hands before they ate).
ReplyDeleteI feel absolved by your post. Don't you feel powerful?
Such a totally AWESOME post!!!! I read it to my sister and we laughed and giggled together - BUT also totally agree with your beliefs!!!! Thank you for saying it all so well!!!!!
ReplyDelete@Anonymous
ReplyDeleteLeft out the 3rd option: read people's blogs and then behave like a troll.
Great post! Many thanks for a good time visiting your web blog.
ReplyDeleteThieves Oil